Sunday, May 10, 2009

A US war crime?

The US is accused of using white phosphorus weapons against civilians in the recent bombings in Farah:

Phosphorus claim after fatal air strikes in Afghanistan
Jon Boone - The Guardian

KABUL, May 10 - Afghanistan's leading human rights organisation is investigating claims that white phosphorus was used during a deadly battle between US forces and the Taliban last week in which scores of civilians may have died.

Nader Nadery, a senior officer at the Afghanistan Independent Human Rights Commission, said the organisation was concerned that the chemical, which can cause severe burns, might have been used in the firefight in Bala Baluk, a district in the western province of Farah.

Dr Mohammad Aref Jalali, the head of an internationally funded burns hospital in Herat, said villagers taken to hospital after the incident had "highly unusual burns" on their hands and feet that he had not seen before. "We cannot be 100% sure what type of chemical it was and we do not have the equipment here to find out. One of the women who came here told us that 22 members of her family were totally burned. She said a bomb distributed white power that caught fire and then set people's clothes alight."

US forces in Afghanistan denied they had used the chemical, and have also said claims that up to 147 civilians were killed were grossly exaggerated...

But members of the human rights department at the UN mission in Afghanistan have been appalled by witness testimony from people in the village, according to one official in Kabul who talked anonymously to the Guardian.

He said bombs were dropped after militants had quit the battlefield, which appeared to be backed up by the US air force's own daily report, which is published online.

"The stories that are emerging are quite frankly horrifying," the official said. "It is quite apparent that the large bulk of civilian casualties were called in after the initial fighting had subsided and both the troops and the Taliban had withdrawn.

"Local villagers went to the mosque to pray for peace. Shortly after evening prayers the air strikes were called in, and they continued for a couple of hours whilst the villagers were frantically calling the local governor to get him to call off the air strikes."

He said that women and children hid inside their homes while their men went on to the roofs with guns. US forces say these men were militants, but the UN official said they were simply villagers and "it is totally normal for them to have guns"... (link)
Here's the American military's daily report on the Farah incident which appears to support the claims of the villagers and which contradicts statements of US military officials:
In Afghanistan, Navy F/A-18F Super Hornets and an Air Force B-1B Lancer were called to carry out air strikes during an engagement between anti-Afghan gunmen and Afghan National Police. The jets hit several enemy fighting positions and a compound in which enemy personnel had gathered after the fight. (link)
More from Reuters:
[Nader Nadery] said the rights commission was alerted to the possibility that white phosphorus munitions may have caused the burns in Farah by a Reuters report last week of a young girl burned by the chemical in another part of the country, the first known account of a casualty from white phosphorus in Afghanistan.

U.S. military doctors who treated that girl had confirmed she was struck by white phosphorus in Kapisa province. The military said it believed none of its shells had struck her house and a Taliban mortar may have been to blame, but rights groups called for the military to reveal more details of its investigation.

Since Reuters disclosed the Kapisa case, the military has released accounts of four incidents it says show that the Taliban use white phosphorus in Afghanistan... (link)
Related:

Friday, May 8, 2009

'Canadian soldiers did not bring peace'

It appears that the mighty spin machine of the Canadian military utterly failed to find an angle on this one:

'Drawback' New Tactic: Military
Brian Hutchinson - National Post

MAY 4 - Canada's military says it has not abandoned villagers in the Taliban-controlled western Panjwaii district, insisting that the "drawback" of troops last week and the dismantling of a Canadian-built police substation are tactical victories.

Tearing down the Mushan substation signals the start of a new strategy that will see Canadian Forces troops move closer to Kandahar city...

The police substation, lately referred to as a strong point, was taken apart and troops were redeployed in a large-scale operation called Munkiredal, the Pashto word for deny.

The name might seem ironic. But Canadian officers say it reflects that the strong point was eliminated and all its equipment removed, thus denying the Taliban any opportunity to claim anything from the site.

In a briefing yesterday with reporters at Kandahar Air Field, officers explained that the 64 Afghan National Army soldiers who were stationed inside the tiny and primitive fortress, along with a rotation of eight Canadian military mentors, had not effectively disrupted insurgent activity in the area. The strongpoint was constantly under siege, according to the military.

Mushan is a hardscrabble agricultural community about 40 kilometres west of Kandahar Air Field. It is now under Taliban control, the officers conceded, as is much of the Panjwaii peninsula...

The strongpoint was built there in 2007 to protect the local population from further Taliban attack, reprisal and recruitment. Two other Canadian-built strong points east of Mushan, in the villages of Talukan and in Zangabad, were dismantled last year. Talukan was the scene of a Taliban-led massacre of civilians in December, 2006.

The entire Panjwaii district area remains an area of Canadian responsibility. The number of Taliban operating there is difficult to determine. Their movements are seasonal, and they concentrate in certain areas. Canadian officers can't say if there are fewer insurgents now compared to three years ago. (link)
So, according to the article, Canadian officers declare the abandonment of Mushan to be a victory because they removed stuff from the outpost before the Taliban could loot it. Classic.

Hutchinson has more, following a discussion with CDS Natynczyk when he accompanied PM Harper on the latter's secret trip to Kandahar recently:
'Taliban hate our guts,' top soldier says
Brian Hutchinson - Canwest News Service

MAY 9 - Villagers in a Taliban-controlled area west of Kandahar City are applauding last week's drawback of Canadian and Afghan troops, saying the presence of coalition forces in their communities had only complicated their lives.

"Canadian and Afghan soldiers did not bring peace into the area where we are living," says one landowner in Mushan village, western Panjwaii district...

Even though insurgents in western Panjwaii are now "walking around freely and with rifles, (residents) are more relaxed than when the fort was here," the man added.

It's not a flattering assessment, but it is one Canada's top soldier accepts.

Chief of Defence Staff Walter Natynczyk told Canwest News Service in an interview this week the Mushan strong point did not help clear the area of Taliban.

Instead, the installation drew insurgents to Mushan like moths to a flame...

The landowner added: "We were living in fear when the fort was there. The Taliban would attack it, and of course the Canadian and Afghan army would react. Civilians suffered casualties." ...

Two other Canadian-built strong points just to the east also were built in 2007, in the villages of Zangabad and Talukan. They were dismantled last year.

In a recent briefing, Canadian officers told reporters that all three substations were constantly under siege. The situation was "untenable," one said... (link)
The recent history of Mushan
It is easy to see why the people of Mushan might be fed up with the foreigners' armed presence in their village. A look at the recent history of the town reveals a sordid record:

In December 2006, Mushan was reportedly cleared of a force of 900 Taliban fighters in Operation Baaz Tsuka, courtesy of US, Canadian and British forces, including British special forces. While the Taliban reportedly executed some two dozen locals before their exit, they didn't put up much of a fight against the occupying forces.

In April 2007, an Afghan police unit set up shop in Mushan and the newly-assigned cops got to work extorting locals for food and money. Soon, the commander of the station had rekindled an old feud with an official of the National Directorate for Security, resulting in armed clashes between the police and NDS which killed perhaps a dozen police.

By June of 2007, the Afghan police force had been removed from the area and the Canadian Forces began an embedded training program with the Afghan police, called POMLT. Canadian military officials assured Globe and Mail reporter Graeme Smith that Panjwai had been mostly pacified by then. "[T]he Panjwai area is one of the safer areas in the province," Canadian Brigadier-General Tim Grant said. It was, however, an obvious lie. Locals at the time told Smith that the Taliban controled parts of the district and it is by now a well-known fact that clearing the area of insurgents has done little to deter them for long.

In May of 2008, Canadian forces refused to adequately compensate farmers in Mushan whose poppy crops were destroyed by Canadian troops while they were building a road. While a neighboring wheat farmer received $1500 in compensation, three poppy farmers, whose losses were as great, received only about $100 a piece.

Australian forces and targeted assassinations

We have seen before on this blog that Australian forces were involved in a targeted assassination of an insurgent leader last fall. Now there is evidence of a repeat performance:

SAS 'assassinate' Taliban leader Mullah Noorullah
Mark Dodd - The Australian

May 7 - Australian special forces have taken part in a targeted assassination of a senior Taliban leader, an operation army commanders claim will disrupt the insurgents' campaign in southern Oruzgan.

Mullah Noorullah was killed ... in Deh Rafshan district in southern Oruzgan, where the Australian Special Operations Task Group is based.

The SOTG tag is commonly used by defence as a synonym to describe elite Special Air Service operatives authorised to hunt and kill Taliban leaders in an Afghan variation on the Vietnam-era Phoenix Program...

Last month, the SOTG claimed credit for killing Mullah Abdul Bari, a former Taliban governor of Helmand province... (link)
The reference to the Phoenix Program is downright sickening. Here is how the program's foremost historian, Douglas Valentine, describes the acts carried out under its authority:
By 1969 the CIA, through Phoenix, was targeting individual VCI [Viet Cong Infrastructure, i.e. peasant supporters] and their families all across Vietnam. Over 20,000 people were assassinated by the end of the year and hundreds of thousands had been tortured in Province Interrogation Centers... (link)
Related:

Real heroes

On May 2, Olympia Port Militarization Resistance activists were arrested attempting to halt the shipment of war machines to Afghanistan:

TACOMA, WA – Activists staged a series of successful direct actions in several locations on the night of May 2, blocking striker vehicles bound for the Port of Tacoma from Fort Lewis. Blockades halted strikers at several points along Interstate 5, and 11 activists were arrested. Demonstrators have pledged to continue resisting the use of the port for war shipments.

The Stryker vehicles were heading to the Port of Tacoma for eventual shipment to Afghanistan in advance of the deployment of the 5th Stryker Brigade, 2nd Infantry Division...

At times police used excessive force against unarmed nonviolent demonstrators. One woman was choked on the strap of her messenger bag while another demonstrator was dragged across the road by his hair while he was shouting that he was nonviolent.

Port Militarization Resistance (PMR) has been actively resisting the use of the publicly owned ports in the Pacific Northwest since 2006. PMR demonstrators share a common goal to "end our community's participation in the occupations of Iraq and Afghanistan by stopping the military use of our Ports." ... (link)
The Seattle Times has an article on the action here.

Afghans rage as US lies

Patrick Cockburn has traveled from Kabul to Herat to report on the aftermath of the American bombings in Farah province:

Afghans riot over air-strike atrocity
Witnesses say deaths of 147 people in three villages came after a sustained bombardment by American aircraft

HERAT, May 8 - Shouting "Death to America" and "Death to the Government", thousands of Afghan villagers hurled stones at police yesterday as they vented their fury at American air strikes that local officials claim killed 147 civilians.

The riot started when people from three villages struck by US bombers in the early hours of Tuesday, brought 15 newly-discovered bodies in a truck to the house of the provincial governor. As the crowd pressed forward in Farah, police opened fire, wounding four protesters. Traders in the rest of Farah city, the capital of the province of the same name where the bombing took place, closed their shops, vowing they would not reopen them until there is an investigation.

A local official Abdul Basir Khan said yesterday that he had collected the names of 147 people who had died, making it the worst such incident since the US intervened in Afghanistan started in 2001. A phone call from the governor of Farah province, Rohul Amin, in which he said that 130 people had died, was played over the loudspeaker in the Afghan parliament in Kabul, sparking demands for more control over US operations...

A claim by American officials, which was repeated by the US Defence Secretary Robert Gates yesterday in Kabul, that the Taliban might have killed people with grenades because they did not pay an opium tax is not supported by any eyewitnesses and is disproved by pictures of deep bomb craters, one of which is filled with water. Mr Gates expressed regret for the incident but did not go so far as to accept blame.

The US admits that it did conduct an air strike at the time and place, but it is becoming clear, going by the account of survivors, that the air raid was not a brief attack by several aircraft acting on mistaken intelligence, but a sustained bombardment in which three villages were pounded to pieces...

The attack was on three villages – Gerani, Gangabad and Koujaha – just off the main road...

Provincial officials, including the governor Rohul Amin, say that in the lead-up to the bombing there was heavy fighting between hundreds of Taliban and the Afghan Army and police. Going by Mr Faizy's account there had been, "a fight some seven or eight kilometres from the three villages in which two Afghan Army and a US Humvee were destroyed. A third Afghan Army vehicle was captured." Three police were killed and four wounded, as was one American and one Afghan army soldier. This was hardly a major military engagement, but the pro-government forces seem to have got the worst of it and their burned out vehicles still stand in the road.

The loss of life in Afghanistan from air strikes is often worse than in Iraq where houses are more modern and usually have basements. In the villages in Farah, people were living in compounds with mud brick walls which crumbled easily. Pictures of the aftermath of the attack show people standing beside the remains of a relative which often only looks like a muddy pile of torn meat. One elderly white bearded man, said by neighbours to have lost 30 members of his family, squats despairingly beside a body that has been torn into shreds. .. (link)

Thursday, May 7, 2009

'Truckloads of bodies, mostly women and children'

Patrick Cockburn sums up the latest outrage:

'120 die' as US bombs village
Patrick Cockburn - The Independent

KABUL, May 7 - A misdirected US air strike has killed as many as 120 Afghans, including dozens of women and children. The attack is the deadliest such bombing involving civilian casualties so far in the eight years since the US-led invasion of Afghanistan.

Families in two villages in Farah province in western Afghanistan were digging for bodies in the ruins of their mudbrick houses yesterday. "There were women and children who were killed," said Jessica Barry, a Red Cross spokeswoman. "It seemed they were trying to shelter in houses when they were hit." Survivors said the number of dead would almost certainly to rise as the search for bodies continued...

US Marine Special Forces supporting the Afghan army apparently called in the air strike on Tuesday on two villages in Bala Baluk district after heavy fighting with the Taliban. Accounts by Afghans of high civilian casualties are often denied or dismissed by US officials. But a team from the Red Cross visited the scene of this attack. "There were bodies, graves, there were people burying bodies when we were there," said Ms Barry. She said a first aid worker for Afghanistan's Red Crescent died with 13 members of his family. "Dozens of dead bodies were seen in the two locations we went to." Rohul Amin, the provincial governor of Farah, told The Independent that "the dead numbered over 100". Villagers brought 30 bodies, including women and children, in a truck to Mr Amin in Farah City to prove it had happened...

The air strikes were preceded by two days of fighting between Afghan government forces supported by the US and dozens of Taliban fighters. Farah is a poor province whose people are mostly farmers and where the Taliban has been very active. The provincial police chief, Abdul Gaffar, said three police officers and 25 Taliban were killed in fighting near the village of Ganjabad in Bala Baluk district.

Local residents later told Afghan officials that they put their children, women and elderly men in walled compounds in the village of Gerani, which is three miles from the scene of the fighting and where they thought they would be safe. It was these compounds which were then attacked from the air and most of the people sheltering inside were killed... (link)
Estimates of the number of casualties in the incident run as high as 150+, according to Afghan officials:
[Abdul Basir Khan, a member of Farah's provincial council] said villagers allege that more than 150 civilians died in the bombing.

Mohammad Nieem Qadderdan, a former district chief of Bala Buluk, said between 100 and 120 people were killed in the attacks... (link)
And elsewhere:
[Jessica] Barry, the ICRC spokesperson, said: "I think that it is important to remember that this is not a one-off situation. There has been a rise in casualties over the last year... (link)
Finally The Times:
Jessica Barry, an ICRC representative, said that an international Red Cross team in Bala Baluk saw “dozens of bodies in each of the two locations” on Tuesday. “There were bodies, there were graves, and there were people burying bodies when we were there,” she said. “We do confirm women and children.”
Denial
True to form*, NATO's commander in Afghanistan, General David McKiernan, has issued a denial of sorts:
"We have some other information that leads us to distinctly different conclusions about the cause of the civilian casualties," McKiernan said. He would not elaborate but said the United States was working with the Afghan government to learn the truth.

A senior U.S. defense official said late Wednesday that Marine special operations forces believe the Afghan civilians were killed by grenades hurled by Taliban militants, who then loaded some of the bodies into a vehicle and drove them around the village, claiming the dead were victims of an American airstrike.

A second U.S. official said a senior Taliban commander is believed to have ordered the grenade attack. The officials spoke on condition of anonymity because they weren't authorized to release the information.

Two other senior defense officials said the grenade report comes from villagers interviewed by U.S. investigators who went to the site, but there is no proof yet that the report is right.

If correct, it would be the first time the Taliban has used grenades in this way, presumably to mimic the effect of a bombing... (link)
Yet locals have a different story:
A girl named Shafiqa wounded in the fighting told Associated Press Television News: "We were at home when the bombing started. Seven members of my family were killed." ... (link)
And finally, the Red Cross seems convinced that airstrikes are the culprit:
Tribal elders called the Red Cross during the fighting to report civilian casualties and ask for help, said Reto Stocker, the agency's head in Afghanistan.

"We know that those killed included an Afghan Red Crescent volunteer and 13 members of his family who had been sheltering from fighting in a house that was bombed in an airstrike," Stocker said... (link)

* It is worth recalling that last summer, when over 90 civilians were killed in a similar incident in Azizabad, US officials initially denied that any civilians were killed, then acknowledged only that a handful were killed, then admitted more were killed, then finally re-investigated months later and admitted a substantial number of dead civilians. Yet, still the US military's count was well below the early reports from various NGO's and the press reporting fromthe scene.

Related:

Blog entries on the Azizabad massacre: First, second, third, fourth.

Addendum:

Jon Boone, writing for the Guardian from Kabul, relates locals' estimates of over 200 victims in the Bala Baluk incident:
Afghanistan police operation leaves devastation behind

KABUL, May 6 - The villagers of Geraani and Gangabad had just finished their breakfast when the Taliban came to their town to collect a so-called tax on the area's poppy farmers...

Some locals estimated the death toll at up to 200...

Village elder Hajji Issa Khan from Gangabad may be more precise because throughout yesterday his tractor was used to carry the dead to a central area where the villagers could mourn their dead and bury them immediately, in accordance with Islamic custom.

"In this operation there were 127 people killed. I can tell you exactly because my driver was carrying those … people to the centre of the town and he came and told me that he carried 127 people." ...

Locals say that the Taliban were "foreigners" – a mixture of Arabs and Chechens as well as Afghans from neighbouring Helmand province...

"It was 8am when the Taliban came. We were in our houses finishing our breakfast," said Hajji Issa Khan, an elderly and obviously anguished man who struggled to finish his sentences, by phone.

"The Taliban went to each house saying that we want to collect the poppy tax. We were talking to them up to almost 10 o'clock when the Afghan forces came. When they came we were inside our houses with the Taliban who would not let us go outside.

"Neither the army nor the police told us they were going to start this operation or gave us a chance to escape." (link)

Tuesday, May 5, 2009

How not to win friends

The Guardian's Brian Whitaker writes about revelations of proselytizing by US troops in Afghanistan:

The US military has been embarrassed by footage broadcast on al-Jazeera television which shows soldiers and a chaplain discussing how to convert Afghans to Christianity...

The US miltary claims the footage was shown out of context and al-Jazeera insists it was not. The troops in the video seem aware that Centcom's General Order Number 1 forbids them from proselytising while on active duty but one says there are ways around this – for example, by presenting people with Bibles as "gifts"... (link)
See the video here.

Monday, May 4, 2009

Aid waste and corruption

Patrick Cockburn, one of the finest foreign correspondents in the world, is in Afghanistan:

Living High on the West's Largesse
By Patrick Cockburn

KABUL, May 1 - [...] The high degree of wastage of aid money in Afghanistan has long been an open secret. In 2006, Jean Mazurelle, the then country director of the World Bank, calculated that between 35 per cent and 40 per cent of aid was "badly spent". "The wastage of aid is sky-high," he said.

"I was in Badakhshan province in northern Afghanistan which has a population of 830,000, most of whom depend on farming," said Matt Waldman, the head of policy and advocacy for Oxfam in Kabul. "The entire budget of the local department of agriculture, irrigation and livestock, which is extremely important for farmers in Badakhshan, is just $40,000. This would be the pay of an expatriate consultant in Kabul for a few months." ...

[M]uch of the aid money goes to foreign companies who then subcontract as many as five times with each subcontractor in turn looking for between 10 per cent and 20 per cent or more profit before any work is done on the project... (link)
Although the picture he paints is bad enough, Cockburn doesn't even mention another aspect of the problems of humanitarian aid delivery in Afghanistan. Namely, the militarization of aid.

As we saw last week, however, there is evidence that Western militaries in Afghanistan have managed to severely distort the context for the delivery of aid. In public opinion surveys, around half of Afghans in Kandahar and Helmand say they oppose the presence of foreign aid organisations. Those looking for a place to point the finger for such a disturbing state of affairs need look first toward the Western militaries and their PRT's and other "aid" delivery projects. And of course aid agencies themselves can repeat an 'I told you so' or two.

Sunday, May 3, 2009

How do you say 'arrogant imperialist' in Russian?

From Maclean's magazine's Michael Petrou:

Afghanistan is a country for which I have deep affection. I was there in the weeks after 9/11 in the company of the anti-Taliban Northern Alliance. It was dangerous. I got sick, shelled, and shot at. Colleagues were killed. But I still remember my time there with fondness and pine to go back. The memory of my Afghan translator, a man who owned very little, pushing gifts into my hands as I left is one I’ll never forget. Because of these memories, even if I believed the Taliban were strictly an Afghan problem, I couldn’t advocate ceding them the country. I care too much about the people who live there... (link)
So, imagine the parallel scene in Russia in say 1986: A Russian journalist with Pravda recalls his days embedded with Russian soldiers in Afghanistan and proclaims that, even if the mujaheddin were not funded by the US and Saudi Arabia, he "could not advocate ceding the mujaheddin the country," because he "cares too much about Afghans." Pretty sick, really. The only responsibility of an (illegal) invader is to get out. No half-measures. No saying, 'We'll get out when we think it's okay to get out.' Just get out.

But comments like Petrou's are considered patriotic and altogether normal in our media. Certainly no commentator would dare point out the rank hypocrisy of such sentiments.

Addendum
Answer to question in blog entry title: заносчивый империалист

Thursday, April 30, 2009

The turncoat

Al Jazeera chats, rather briefly it seems, with a very unusual insurgent:

Switching sides in Afghanistan
By Qais Azimy

HELMAND, Apr 27 - A man with a long, black beard gets out of a Toyota, with four other Taliban fighters in tow...

It is immediately obvious that he is not Afghan.

The other Taliban fighters say he is an Arab who came to Afghanistan with the "infidel fighters". But he never fought with them - he fled the Sangen district base he had been assigned to and surrendered to the Taliban in his full military gear.

That was two years ago...

He introduces himself as Mustafa. I ask him for his second name.

"Just call me Mustafa," he said.

"Everyone in the United Arab Emirates (UAE) knows me. They all know my story," he says...

Mustafa says he had come to Afghanistan as a member of the UAE contingent to the Nato-led International Security Assistance Force (Isaf).

The UAE, which previously was one of three countries which had formally recognised the Taliban after their capture of Kabul in 1996, has approximately 25 troops serving with Isaf in Afghanistan, according to figures released in April 2009...

Mustafa says he had qualms that his service within Isaf was wrong, so instead of fighting the Taliban, he fled the base and joined the Taliban who welcomed him with open arms.

Now he is considered one the most revered and respected Taliban fighters in Helmand province... (link)
Related: